20 November 2026
What to check for hidden conflicts in financial advice
Presented by @advicepracticenotes
When a client sits down with a financial planner, they bring a set of goals, a level of trust, and an expectation that the advice they receive puts their interests first. In practice, that expectation can be subtly undermined by conflicts of interest that the client never sees. A planner might recommend a product partly because it pays a higher commission, or steer a portfolio toward an in-house fund because it benefits the firm. These pressures exist even when the planner intends to do right by the client. The challenge is to spot them before they shape the outcome.
For anyone engaged in independent financial planning, the ability to identify conflicts of interest is a core skill. It is not about assuming bad faith; it is about creating a process that surfaces hidden incentives so they can be managed or removed. Below is a practical checklist of points to examine when reviewing a planner, a firm, or even your own recommendations.
1. Check how the planner is paid
The most direct conflict in financial advice comes from the payment structure. A planner who earns commissions, trailing fees, or volume bonuses from product providers has a financial incentive to recommend those products over others. The conflict is not always obvious: a low upfront fee might be offset by a generous ongoing commission that depends on the client staying in a particular fund.
What to ask: Does the planner disclose every source of their compensation? Are they willing to show you a dollar figure for each product they recommend? If they cannot or will not break it down, that is a red flag. In an advice-only model, the planner charges a fee directly to the client and accepts no third-party payments. This arrangement removes the most common source of bias and makes the planner's income transparent.
2. Look at the range of products considered
A planner who works within a limited panel of products may be making good choices within that panel, but the client never sees what is left out. The conflict here is not about commission; it is about convenience, habit, or an agreement with a particular platform. Some firms restrict the products their advisers can recommend to those on an approved list. That list may be shaped by revenue-sharing agreements rather than client outcomes.
What to ask: How many providers do you regularly use? Can you show me examples of times you recommended a product from outside your usual list? A planner committed to product neutral planning will consider the whole market, not a preselected subset. They should be able to explain why a particular product fits the client's situation, not just why it fits the firm's panel.
3. Examine the planner's relationship with product providers
Close ties between a planning firm and a product manufacturer can create a conflict that operates below the surface. A planner who sits on an advisory board for an insurance company, receives sponsored trips, or earns bonuses for hitting sales targets has a personal interest in steering clients toward that provider. These arrangements are often described as "education" or "partnership," but they reward loyalty to the provider, not to the client.
What to ask: Do you receive any benefits from product providers beyond standard professional courtesies? Have you ever been offered an incentive to increase the volume of business you place with a particular firm? The answer should be a clear no, or the planner should explain how they manage that conflict transparently with clients.
4. Look for implicit pressure from the firm's culture
Not all conflicts are financial. A firm that publicly emphasises client outcomes but internally rewards advisers for retention rates, assets under management growth, or product placement creates a cultural conflict. Advisers learn that their career progression depends on numbers that may not align with the client's best interests. This pressure can be subtle: a bonus for keeping clients in a particular fund, a promotion tied to fee revenue, or simply the expectation that advisers sell a certain number of insurance policies each quarter.
What to ask: How does your firm measure success for its advisers? Is there any metric that could create a tension between what is best for the client and what is best for the adviser's career? A firm that cannot answer this question openly is likely relying on those unspoken pressures.
5. Check for disclosure that is complete and timely
Even when a conflict exists, it can be managed if it is disclosed clearly and early. The problem is that disclosure is often buried in fine print, delivered after the recommendation is made, or phrased in a way that minimises its significance. A client might sign a statement acknowledging that the planner receives commissions without realising how much those commissions influence the options presented.
What to ask: Before you make a recommendation, can you tell me all the ways you benefit from it? Can you put that in writing, in a single page, without jargon? If the planner hesitates or points to a multi-page document, the disclosure is not serving its purpose. Effective disclosure empowers the client to evaluate the advice with full knowledge of the planner's incentives.
6. Consider the planner's duty and how it is enforced
Fiduciary duty is a legal obligation to act in the client's best interest. Not every planner operates under this duty. Some follow a suitability standard, which only requires that the product be appropriate for the client, not that it be the best option available. The difference matters because suitability leaves room for the planner's own interests to tip the scale.
What to ask: Do you act as a fiduciary for all your clients at all times? Is that commitment written into your engagement letter? If the planner says they do, ask how they handle situations where their own compensation conflicts with the client's best option. A planner who truly embraces fiduciary duty will have a process for identifying and eliminating those conflicts, not just disclosing them.
7. Review the recommendation process for signs of bias
Even when a planner has good intentions, cognitive biases can shape their recommendations. Anchoring on a familiar product, confirmation bias toward a favoured strategy, or overconfidence in a particular investment theme can lead to advice that is not in the client's best interest. These biases are not venal, but they are still conflicts of interest between the planner's mental shortcuts and the client's needs.
What to ask: Can you walk me through the steps you take to test your own recommendations? Do you ever present the client with more than one reasonable option and explain the trade-offs? A planner who relies on a single path every time may be overlooking alternatives that would serve the client better. product neutral planning requires that the planner actively seek out and consider a range of possibilities before narrowing to a recommendation.
Using this checklist does not guarantee that every conflict will be caught. Some are deeply embedded in the structure of the industry or in the planner's own habits. But going through these points with a planner gives the client a much clearer picture of where the advice comes from and whose interests it truly serves. For the planner, it serves as a self-audit that keeps the focus where it belongs: on the client. In independent financial planning, the goal is not to eliminate every possible conflict overnight; it is to build a practice where conflicts are surfaced, examined, and addressed before they affect the quality of the recommendation.